When a similar law came to light and failed
in Kansas, I thought it would just be a one-time fluke. A conservative, fly-over state with no real
influence making a play to get on the national state by trying to pass a law
that would allow businesses to discriminate based on a person’s sexual
orientation. When the bill predictably
(or so I thought) failed in the state senate, I was convinced that Kansas Governor
Sam Brownback’s public support for the bill was nothing more than political
pandering to the base. He knew the bill
would fail so why not take a strong stand for it and achieve a moral victory as
a martyr for the cause. Then
Arizona happened.
Let’s be completely honest for a moment. While the bill is titled
as relating to the free exercise of religion, it’s plainly obvious to anyone
with any common sense that it’s simply about legalizing discrimination and
bigotry. The idea that anyone who owns
or operates a public business can
legally refuse to serve potential customers based on that person’s sexual
orientation is simply mind-boggling. Are
we in some time vortex which has sucked us back to Jim Crowe era America? Supporters
of the bill, aka conservative Christians, like to say this is about “religious freedom.” Since when does exercising one’s freedom
allow you the right to impose on someone else’s?
The whole “religious freedom” mantra is being repeated with
the same frequency and intensity as the one-percenters kept proclaiming
themselves “job creators.” Both claims
are worthless and hollow—yet to those who think giving rich people more money
when our economy is based on consumer spending, “religious freedom” as the
right to legalized bigotry makes perfect sense.
Religious freedom in America has been about the right to individual “soul
liberty”—not the right to bash someone else over the head with that personal
belief. I can believe whatever I want—but that doesn’t
mean I can necessarily live out those beliefs in the public sphere. America is—for better or worse—a democratic
society where majority rule shapes the public values and guidelines. And again, while the public can’t force you
to believe a certain thing, it can mandate that you behave a certain way.
The idea of “religious freedom” now meaning the ability to behave in accordance with your own
personal thoughts or belief system is entirely problematic. Suppose I am a business owner who believes
pre-marital sex is wrong; do I know have the right to refuse contraceptives and
maternity coverage to all my single female employees? If I think all Muslims
are going to hell can I ban them from my restaurant? If it is my sincerely held belief that white
people are the master race—can I begin seeking to eliminate all other
races? “Religious Freedom” in America
has traditionally referred to individual “soul liberty,” or the idea for each person
to think or believe however they see fit.
With this new law—and the changing definition of the word—conservatives
are essentially re-defining “religious freedom” as the ability to behave
however I see fit, regardless of standard public practice or law.
More brilliant conservative logic! |
And, what’s most shockingly, mind-numbingly, ridiculous
about the bills in Arizona and Kansas is that they are nearly universally and
exclusively supported by conservative Christians. Yes, those same conservative Christians that
are constantly wailing about they themselves being “persecuted.” Yes, those
same conservative Christians that every Christmas season play-up the made-up “War
on Christmas.” That these same
conservative Christians, who despite their obvious hegemonic influence over
American culture, have this delusional, fantastical notion that they themselves
are being discriminated against can then turn around and support legalized
discrimination of an actual minority
group which is actually facing legitimate
bullying, persecution, and discrimination is nothing short of ridiculous. Frankly, it’s beyond ridiculous. It’s
moronic, stupendous, and completely hypocritical. Can any of us really not imagine the
hullabaloo that would come about if some state tried to pass a law which allowed business owners the right to refuse
service to Christians!?
A foundational principle of America is the right for individuals
to believe what they want to believe.
While this has been ignored at different stages throughout our history
such as in Puritanical New England or the McCarthy blacklists of the 1950’s, religious
freedom—when properly practiced—is an exceptional part of what makes America
great. Just as I do not wish to be told
what to believe, I have no desire to tell others, yet there is a huge
difference between belief and behavior.
Believe what you want, but you must behave within the confines of the
law. And whatever you believe, don’t use that belief as an
excuse to hate.